Top 30 Playmates

[wozhere]

I love this topic - don't know why I didn't notice this thread before.
Interesting the wide range of varying tastes everyone has.

I hope you don't mind me bending the rules a little...
I started my own list at PBs 45th anniversary by picking my fave 45.
Once a year, I update that list (I know, I'm a dork ) and also lengthen it by one to coincide with the number of years of PBs existence, which is now nearly 57 years. I added a new name early this year 'cause of this year's Miss July Shanna McLaughlin (check her out, if you haven't already - best pm in a decade).

So my list is top 57... I hope that isn't too long and boring to read. My next post with have cfs to make it a little less boring (I hope )

In reading your posts there were comments about weird 50s-60s hairstyles etc. I saw past the bad hair styles when I made my choices... and you guys seem to have overlooked the blond bombshell era of the 50s... some great VINTAGE pms have been left out... and how can any list not include the girl that started it all for us?... Marilyn

So here goes ... I definitely would welcome some feed-back (positive or negative)

01. Janet Lupo Nov/75
02. Melinda Windsor Feb/66
03. Brande Roderick Apr/00
04. Kimberly Conrad Jan/88
05. Kelly Gallagher Sep/94
06. Cynthia Myers Dec/68
07. Shanna McLaughlin Jul/10
08. Victoria Zdrok Oct/94
09. Nichole Van Croft Oct/00
10. Stacy Arthur Jan/91
11. Anna Nicole Smith May/92
12. Stacy Sanches Mar/95
13. Marianne Gravatte Oct/82
14. Shauna Sand May/96
15. Jayne Mansfield Feb/55
16. Melissa Holliday Jan/95
17. Pamela Anderson Feb/90
18. Carrie Stevens Jun/97
19. Rebecca Ramos Jan/03
20. Katie Lohmann Apr/01
21. Joey Gibson Jun/67
22. Buffy Tyler Nov/00
23. Eve Meyer Jun/55
24. Nikki Scheiler Sep/97
25. Terri Welles Dec/80
26. Karen Price Jan/81
27. Marilyn Lange May/74
28. Kym Malin May/82
29. Marilyn Cole Jan/72
30. Divini Rae Nov/03
31. Cara Wakelin Nov/99
32. Shannon Long Oct/88
33. Jaime Bergman Jan/99
34. Suzi Simpson Jan/92
35. Brooke Richards Dec/99
36. Destiny Davis Jan/05
37. Patricia Farinelli Dec/81
38. Karen Foster Oct/89
39. Leisa Sheridan Jul/93
40. Kimberly McArthur Jan/82
41. Carol Imhof Dec/70
42. Karen Christy Dec/71
43. Alana Soares Mar/83
44. Cheryl Bachman Oct/91
45. Kimberly Donley Mar/93
46. Marilyn Monroe Dec/53
47. Lauren Anderson Jul/02
48. Sherry Arnett Jan/86
49. Julie Peterson Feb/87
50. Jan Roberts Aug/62
51. Karen Witter Mar/82
52. Deanna Brooks May/98
53. Liz Glazowski Apr/80
54. Sharon Rogers Jan/64
55. India Allen Dec/87
56. Candy Loving Jan/79
57. Patti McGuire Nov/76

Man, that was a lot of typing

[wozhere]

Here's the visual evidence for my picks...

[gbt42dd]

Concur with most picks, but I would eliminate several of your selections with fake boobs for these gorgeous naturals:

Charlotte Kemp
(12/1982)

Fran Gerard
(03/1967)

Pamela Anne Gordon
(03/1962)

Nancy Cameron - only front and back PMOM
(01/1974)

Cathy Larmouth (RIP)
(06/1981)

Angela Melini
(06/1992)

and my personal favorite, the fabulous

Miriam Gonzalez
(03/2001)

However, to each his own...........

[wozhere]

Originally Posted by gbt42dd

Concur with most picks, but I would eliminate several of your selections with fake boobs for these gorgeous naturals:

Charlotte Kemp
Fran Gerard
Pamela Anne Gordon
Nancy Cameron - only front and back PMOM
Cathy Larmouth (RIP)
Angela Melini (06/1992)
and my personal favorite, the fabulous
Miriam Gonzalez
However, to each his own...........

Thanks for the reply. The girls you mentioned are good ones. Gonzales & Gerard almost made my list; tough cuts, especially Miriam. Fake boobs don't bother me as long as they were done well. Size is a higher priority than natural There are some playmates with hideous boob jobs that would never make the list.

I hate to break it to you friend, but Cathy Larmouth's (RIP) were fake.

p.s. let's see your Top 30

[Pukindog]

Jayne Mansfield
Lisa Winters
Christa Speck
Cynthia Myers
Carol Imhof
Cyndi Wood
Daina House
Pamela Jean Bryant
Denise McConnell
Lisa Welch
Linda Rhys Vaughn
Lynda Wiesmeier - 2
Cathy St. George
Alana Soares
Tracy Vaccaro
Justine Greiner
Kimberly Evenson
Debi Johnson
Cher Butler
Cynthia Brimhall
Lynne Austin
Anna Clark
Sharry Konopski - 1
Gwen Hajek
Brandi Brandt
Shannon Long
Petra Verkaik
Stacy Leigh Arthur
Carrie Jean Yazel
Cady Cantrell - 3
Angela Melini
Tiffany Sloan
Carrie Westcott
Holly Witt
Shauna Sand
Kelly Monaco
Angela Little
Jaime Bergman
Brande Roderick
Nichole Van Croft
Miriam Gonzalez
Katie Lohmann
Crista Nicole
Heather Spytek
Jennifer Walcott
Stephanie Heinrich
Lindsey Vuolo
Christi Shake
Lani Todd
Charis Boyle
Destiny Davis
Amanda Paige
Christine Smith
Sara Jean Underwood
Tiffany Selby


Sorry, but I couldn't stop at 30. But these are my all time favorites. The top three are listed with numbers after their name.

[wozhere]

Originally Posted by Pukindog

Sorry, but I couldn't stop at 30. But these are my all time favorites. The top three are listed with numbers after their name.

Very difficult to stop 30 out of nearly 700, I stopped at 57 but had to leave out about 50 other favorites, including some you mentioned. Except for a few, I liked most of your choices. You picked Konopski #1 - shame what happened to her, but from what I've read, she seems to be holding up pretty well.

p.s. - I like your avatar

[Ryu Tendoh]

Long time lurker, first time poster!

A Top Pl@ymate list and Karen Price doesn't get mentioned until post #19? For shame!!!!!

Very difficult question indeed, an interesting exercise deep in philosophy and on how erect the member gets when their names are mentioned. I can't think of 30 off hand, but could make up something based on whether I saw them as Pl@ym@tes first or elsewhere in the world before discovering their Pl@yboy spreads.

Am in agreement that most mid-90s and later spreads are barely worth the four-color process they're printed with.

These I know as Pl@ym@tes first, in no order other than my crappy memory for these things:

Cynthia Myers
Barbara Hillary
Julie Woodson [always helps to be the ones who were new[ish] and were bought by dad or older brother when the puberty hits! Julie and Barbara were wanked to quite a bit in my teenage youth...]

Karen Price [will need to see more movies and try and spot her as a stunt woman... without looking it up I only know she's credited in The Running Man for stunts]

Cathy Larmouth
Kelly Tough
Marianne Gravatte
Kym Malin
Patricia Farinelli
Dona Speir [without a doubt the best Andy Sidaris movies were the ones with Dona in them!]

Candy Loving [ok, everybody knows she's the 25th Anniversary Pl@ymate, but can anyone name the 50th without looking it up, and does anyone really give half a rip about it?]

Kimberly MacArthur
Patti McGuire
Jeana Tomasino
Debbie Boostrom
Ola Ray
Daina House

Now for those who I saw elsewhere before the Pl@yboy:

Julie McCullough
Kristine Hanson [I saw her almost every day for a long time on my local teevee as the news and weather girl, years before seeing her spread!]

Rosanne Katon
Lynda Wiesmeier
Charlotte Kemp
Marilyn Monroe [one of my dad's best wartime friends was Roy Craft who was one of Marilyn's publicists at 20th Century Fox her first few years in Hollywood and who is mentioned in the pictorial article of Pl@yboy #1. Roy escaped out of the business and bought a small newspaper in Washington state to hide from the hounds when she got too big to manage, so you never hear much about Mr. Craft in any of the Marilyn biographies. Am hoping Hugh Hefner will do a local autograph show or appearance before too long where I could have an opportunity to ask if he remembers Mr. Craft...]

Jayne Mansfield
Petra Verkaik
Erika Eleniak
Dorothy Stratten

I'm sure there's more, and counting them it's close enough to 30! Mission accomplished!!!!

And while not a Pl@ymate, I have to mention Barbi Benton, who also got the teenage hormones a flowing

[Jacova_fan]

Some good lists have been compiled here, but I think many of you have over-looked Lisa Matthews!! (from my State of Illinois, BTW...) Gentlemen, go to her thread, look at absolute perfection, and when you return from the bathroom to your computers I'm sure this oversight will be corrected.

[tommytimp]

1. Nicki Thomas-Best ass in the history of creation, and the two sexiest non-centerfold photos ever taken for the magazine.
2. Mercy Rooney-Best blonde.
3. Cathy Larmouth(RIP)-Gorgeous. My favorite body type.
4. Ursula Buchfellner
5. Anne-Marie Fox
6. Alana Soares
7. Karen Witter
8. Marilyn Lange
9. Kimberly McArthur
10. Kelly Tough
11. Rosanne Katon
12. Charlotte Kemp
13. Patti Farinelli
14. Karin Taylor
15. Lillian Muller

The next 15 are subject to change at a moment's nitice, but that top 15 is pretty set in stone.

[otokonomidori]

Originally Posted by tommytimp

1. Nicki Thomas-Best ass in the history of creation,
2

I agree